Why Breaking Family Traditions Can Feel Like Betrayal.
When Latinas break traditions, we can feel relief, guilt, sadness and freedom, sometimes all in the same day. Our families may feel disappointed or interpret our decision as rejection. And we may begin creating something we didn’t realize we were allowed to have: a tradition of our own.
I know because I still remember what it felt like to tell my family we weren’t coming home for the holidays.
My husband and I lived in Denver. My family was in New York. We had two very young daughters, and we decided to stay home for Thanksgiving and Christmas.
Thanksgiving was hard. Christmas was harder.
I wanted to see my family. I wanted the crowded house, the busy mornings and all those people doing different things. Some relatives were coming partly because we would be there, which made our absence feel even bigger.
There was so much I loved about going home.
There was also a price I could no longer keep paying.
When Keeping a Tradition Costs Too Much
Traveling over the holidays is hectic before you add babies and toddlers.
We had two little girls close in age. There were supplies to pack, routines to disrupt and a two-hour time difference. There were crying babies on airplanes and nights when we were already barely sleeping.
Getting there took a lot out of us.
But the travel was only part of it. Some of what happened during those visits was painful enough that I would make promises to myself while I was there: I will never do this again. I will never put myself through this again.
Then I would return to Denver, get back into my life and somehow put those feelings away. The next holiday would come around, and I would remember everything I loved about being with my family.
I would go back.
After I got married, my husband became the person who remembered what I had asked myself to forget.
“You told me to remind you that you said you would never do this again.”
His well-being was affected too. Then I began seeing how these experiences could affect our daughters, including what it meant for them to see me so upset.
I had tolerated that cycle for myself for years. Seeing my children begin to be affected helped me decide that something had to change.
Why Changing a Tradition Can Feel Like Betrayal
In conversations with other Latinas through my work, one word comes up again and again when we talk about going against family expectations: betrayal.
That word may sound extreme to someone outside the experience. If you understand it, though, you probably understand it immediately.
You say, “We’re staying home this Christmas.”
You worry they hear, “You don’t matter enough for us to come.”
You say, “This is too much for me this year.”
You worry they hear, “What matters to you doesn’t matter to me.”
In some families, doing something for yourself gets interpreted as a statement about how much you value everyone else. A decision about travel becomes a question of love, loyalty and whether you are still the person they expect you to be.
That is part of what makes these decisions so difficult. You’re trying to care for yourself while facing the possibility that people you love will experience your choice as rejection.
The Disappointment May Actually Happen
My family was upset. They wanted us to change our minds.
The first conversation was difficult, and the conversations that followed kept bringing us back to the same decision.
“I can’t believe you’re not coming.”
“We’re so upset you’re not coming.”
“What if we buy the tickets?”
The offers to help may have addressed the logistics, but they didn’t change what we needed. We had decided to stay home.
Even on the holiday itself, there was guilt and pressure.
I wish I could tell you that making the decision was the hardest part and everything afterward felt easy. That wasn’t my experience.
You Can Miss the Tradition You Needed to Change
That first Christmas at home was bittersweet.
I missed waking up in a house full of people. I missed the activity, the laughter and the feeling of everyone being together.
The good was really good.
I think that deserves to be said because it’s part of why changing a tradition can hurt so much. There may be something beautiful you are giving up alongside something painful you need to step away from.
I missed the good. I didn’t miss the bad.
And when I went back for later visits, I would remember why staying home had mattered.
For me, missing my family was real. So were the reasons we had made our decision. Both deserved to be remembered.
Every Latina Will Have Her Own Experience
Recently, I asked on social media, “What would a good Latina in your family never do?”
One woman shared that she spends Christmas at a cabin instead of with her family. She described being happy with that choice and having no regrets.
Her response stayed with me because my experience included so much longing. Hers sounded different.
There is no single emotional response we all have to changing a family tradition. Some of us miss the gathering deeply. Others feel an enormous sense of relief. Some feel both.
Even talking about these choices publicly can feel taboo. I see that when I invite people to share their experiences. These are things many of us are still figuring out how to say.
How Do You Know When a Tradition Needs to Change?
For me, the question is what participating repeatedly costs you.
No family gathering is perfect. I wouldn’t expect every holiday to be a ten out of ten. There is effort involved in being together, and ordinary frustrations are part of being human.
But I pay attention when the experience leaves me in tears, making vows that I will never put myself through it again.
If you’re considering changing a tradition, ask yourself:
- What do I love about this experience?
- What happens while I’m there that makes me want to leave?
- How does participating affect me and the people coming with me?
- When I get home, do I minimize what happened until I agree to do it again?
- What would I choose for this holiday if I took my own needs seriously?
I wish it had been easier for me to take my suffering seriously before I saw the effect on my husband and children.
You deserve to include yourself in that consideration too.
How to Tell Your Family You’re Doing Something Different
I don’t think you need to share every painful feeling in order to communicate your decision.
You can keep some things private. You can also give a general explanation without presenting a 15-point argument.
For example:
“We’ve decided to spend Christmas at home this year. Traveling with the girls is too much for us, and we need a less hectic holiday.”
The more details you offer, the more opportunities people have to propose solutions.
If you say it’s expensive, someone may offer to pay. If you list five logistical problems, someone may try to solve all five.
You can acknowledge the offer and return to your decision:
“Thank you for offering. We’ve decided to stay home this year.”
Or:
“I know you’re disappointed. We’ll miss you too. We’re still going to spend Christmas at home.”
A brief explanation can be enough. You can love someone and let them be disappointed without reopening the decision every time you talk.
Try One Holiday Before Deciding About Every Holiday
You don’t have to decide what you will do for the rest of your life.
Stay home once.
Experience one holiday without putting yourself in the situation you’ve been dreading. Notice what you miss, what feels better and how it feels to consider your own needs.
Then decide about the next occasion.
Taking it one holiday at a time helped me see that I could make a choice for myself without treating it as a permanent rejection of my family.
That is something I explore in my book, What Will They Say?: understanding yourself as a person with feelings and desires of your own while navigating expectations from people you love.
You are a separate person. You get to discover what caring for yourself feels like.
Making Room for Traditions of Your Own
Our holidays look different now.
We take a family walk. We eat throughout the day. We watch movies, take our time opening presents and play games.
Over the years, those things became our traditions.
I still miss the full house in New York. I think I probably always will.
But I also love what we have created. It’s small, it’s sweet and it’s ours.
So what happens when Latinas break traditions?
Sometimes people are upset. Sometimes we grieve something we loved. Sometimes we discover how much we needed a different experience.
And sometimes, years later, we look around at the family traditions we’ve created and realize how much began with one difficult sentence:
“This year, we’re staying home.”